media examples
Newsweek published this article claiming how bushmeat, wild meat or game, could possibly spread Ebola to America. It stated that bushmeat could be a potential vector for the disease and bring the disease to America through importation. The way this article spoke about bushmeat was criticized in Africa Today, where Monson explains how it reinforces xenophobia by referred bushmeat as dirty and how it makes Africans and African immigrants seen as this “other” and dehumanizes them"(Monson 13) This media example represents the fear and cultural misconceptions about West Africa that sort of "blamed" West Africans for the possible spread of Ebola to America. This perspective takes West African culture out of context and is used as ammunition for how West Africa is responsible for the disease and Americans are not. This narrative was brought up in our focus group when discussing how it's their problem and not America’s problem.
In 2014 there were two students starting school in New Jersey from Rwanda even though Rwanda is not a country affected by Ebola fear circulated the school about contracting the disease. Due to parent's concerns the parents of the children from Rwanda had to quarantine their children for 3 weeks before going to school. This reinforces the view that Americans need to protect themselves first and xenophobia. In Africa today this was criticized by how the media constantly referred Africans as the "other" and that they should just stay in their country. This is represented in this media example from how they saw the students as a threat and they should deal with their disease and stay over there (Monson 12). This theme of Americans wanting to protect themselves was prevalent through our interviews and focus group. Focus group participants explained how people were afraid of contracting Ebola, and that the fear was also spoken about in their high schools. This educational institution greatly contributed to the spread of misinformation, because Americans are socialized to trust the information they learn in school. Both the interview with Dr. Noll and the interview with Dr. Nwangu had a heavy focus on the American narrative, and the inclination to ignore a problem when it does not personally affect them.
On Fox News Sunday, reporter George Will spread misinformation about Ebola despite health officials’ claims that the disease cannot be spread through water, air, or food. Will went on Fox News and said that Ebola can be spread through a sneeze or a cough. Fox News is a popular news outlet that people trust to get their information from. When someone with that power states that misinformation, it can cause a lot of fear in the people watching the news and contribute to the spread of incorrect information. This could only add to the existing anxiety and fear around the Ebola virus. The fear mongering that happened as a result of this miscommunication was significant to the public perception of Ebola and West Africans. During our interview with Dr. Noll, he explained the importance of correctly conveying scientific information to the public and the lack thereof that occurred during this outbreak. His article in UConn Today was his method of combating the spread of misinformation and providing readers with scientifically correct information while keeping it accessible to readers of all levels of scientific literacy.
CNBC, a popular news outlet, reported that the Ebola virus is a "horrible way to die and there's no vaccine," alongside a photo of health workers dressed in their personal protective equipment (PPE). The article states how Americans "need to be prepared" and how West African burial practices "spread the disease." Important to note is that the many cultures in this region should not be generalized to a single “West African culture,” but that this was assumed through a frame of ignorance. They said when they are burying the dead they need to shave their head or braid their hair. This report makes it hard to understand the culture in West Africa and what their burial practices mean to them. These burial practices outlined in the CNBC article directly interfere with prevention methods thus causing the tension between the community and the public health workers. When other countries came to West Africa they did little to understand their culture when trying to provide aid. Our expert interview with Dr. Nwangwu said how his team was on the ground in West Africa and how his own team had assumptions and biases themselves. Due to his team’s preconceived biases they had a hard time communicating and making the community feel comfortable in their presence. In addition, our focus group remembered these hazmat suits and how it made them feel scared about the disease itself. This media coverage of the epidemic was evident without focus group findings as students saw these suits as a representation of fear and anxiety.
Media analysis
In “Where It Hurts: 2014 Year in Review” Morris explains the differences between how anthropologists use culture and how the media uses culture. Culture was used by anthropologists to help manage the present Ebola crisis via medical practice. While the media used the term “culture” to create this “other” being and focused on “anti-modern” cultural practices that worsened the spread of Ebola due to their “consumption of wild meats, an investment in sorcery as both an explanation and a cure for Ebola Infection” (Morris 542). The creation of this “other” dehumanized West Africans and portrayed them as more of a threat to Americans’ health instead of a group of people that needed help. This also added to a narrative of the outbreak not being an American problem and instead transformed it to be a source of fear and hesitation to provide aid. West Africa is a place where there are multiple obstacles that make it unique for them to battle an epidemic. They faced colonialism and corruption and deal with the disadvantage of not being as developed as other countries. The structural and medical inequities were not taken into account when thinking about providing aid and how that looks different in West Africa. Due to the corruption and past government abuses, West African communities were superstitious of health workers. This is supported by Dr. Nwangwu’s experiences of working in Guinea during the outbreak and having to earn the trust of the citizens. The superstition held by the West African people was twisted by the media to explain that they were incompentent and noncompliant to state-led quarantine measures (Morris 542). However, the involuntary quarantines of certain areas led to more injuries and deaths due to rioting than would have been prevented from Ebola (Pellecchia 15). Umberto Pellecchia’s case study of the quarantine of West Point, Monrovia in Liberia is a prime example of the mistrust fabricated between the citizens under quarantine and the government workers.
Key themes in the media were racism, fear, cultural misconceptions, and misinformation. The overarching concept that links all of these themes together is the lack of cultural humility, which is the practice of understanding others’ viewpoints and perspectives with the goal of working together. Instead of trying to understand the complex cultures of West Africa, it was overlooked and medical professionals took what they saw as unwillingness to comply with medical care and turned it into fear. Multiple media outlets blamed West Africa for spreading the virus due to their cultural burial practices and focused on how that makes them "different" than us. In the Scientific American, medical anthropologist Theresa MacPhail criticizes how the media portrayed Ebola and how the “racist rhetoric" used West African culture to blame them for contracting and spreading the Ebola virus (Horgan 2014). The media brought up burial practices, wild game, and noncompliance that promotes the spread of Ebola. MacPhail also discusses how Ebola introduces another avenue for journalists to paint Africa as dirty or undeveloped. This rhetoric shared by journalists gives a negative influence to the public eye when talking about Ebola in West Africa, and thus will make them hesitant of sending aid. This influenced Americans views on Ebola due to the racist messages online that spread fear and misinformation.
Citations
Horgan, John 2014 Scientific American . Scientific American . https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/ebola-8220-fear-mongering-8221-critiqued-by-medical-anthropologist/, accessed November 11, 2019
Monson, S. (2017). Ebola as African: American Media Discourses of Panic and Otherization. Africa Today, 63(3), 3–27. https://doi-org.ezproxy.lib.uconn.edu/10.2979/africatoday.63.3.02
​
Morris, C. D. (2015), Where It Hurts: 2014 Year in Review. AMERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST, 117: 540-552. doi:10.1111/aman.12284
​
Pellecchia, Umberto. “Quarantine and Its Malcontents: How Liberians Responded to the Ebola Epidemic Containment Measures.” Anthropology in Action, vol. 24, no. 2, 1 June 2017, pp. 15–22., doi:10.3167/aia.2017.240203.